Active

69 Orange Street

Brooklyn NY, 11201

$8,950,000


$9,040.40 per sqft

Active

4 Beds

3 Baths

990 sqft

Other

Built in 1829

One of Brooklyn Heights' oldest historic homes can now be yours. This extraordinary home is on the market for the first time in almost 100 years. Built in 1829, this house was built in the Federal clapboard style, and features Victorian add-ons such as the mansard roof with gingerbread details. The distinctive architecture of this house gives it unmatched curb appeal.

69 Orange has been meticulously preserved by the current owners and contains all original features, such as handrails, woodworking, hardware, molding, and historical milk paint. The large backyard has a surprising amount of green space and a bluestone patio perfect for entertaining. This generously sized home has four sizable bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, a library, a salon, a formal dining room, and two spaces that work great for a home office or nursery. The house is fully equipped with Central AC, and washer and dryer, plus a mechanical basement lined with large blocks of stone, along with six fireplaces, five of which are fully functional. This home has a rich history. Originally, this property was owned by Sarah Gracie, daughter of Martha Middagh (Van Nostrand), who named the Brooklyn Heights "Fruit Streets". The Gracie and Middagh families were well-known in the early years of the New York City luxury real estate market, as evidenced by the Gracie mansion on the Upper East Side which is now home to the New York City Mayor.

The houses' fascinating past does not stop there. 69 Orange Street is settled directly next to the iconic Plymouth Church, which has a long history with the abolitionist movement in the United States. The first preacher at Plymouth church, Henry Ward Beecher, was a prominent and well-known abolitionist who dedicated himself to the cause of freedom. Even Beecher's sister, Harriet Beecher Stowe, was committed, as she was the author of the American Classic and anti-slavery book Uncle Tom's Cabin. Henry Ward Beecher's fame attracted thousands to visit the church, including Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Abraham Lincoln, and Mark Twain, who walked past 69 Orange Street on their way to the church. Plymouth church was a well-known hub of the Underground Railroad, and legend has it that enslaved people making the journey were taken in and given sanctuary at 69 Orange Street, as one of the house's owners, Henry L. Pratt was the deacon of Plymouth Church during the Beecher years.

69 Orange Street is located in Brooklyn's highly desirable neighborhood, Brooklyn Heights. Brooklyn Heights is the perfect balance of exciting, fast-paced city life and comfortable suburban relaxation. 69 Orange Street is located within walking distance of Cadman Plaza Park and Whitman Park, as well as many great restaurants and shops. This property is located conveniently close to the High St- Brooklyn Bridge and Clark St subway stations.

RPLU-5122151833

MLS ID

June 16, 2023

Listed

May 13, 2024

Updated

Map

69 Orange Street
Brooklyn NY, 11201

Interior Features

Total Stories

3


Bedrooms

4


Total Bathrooms

3


Full Bathrooms

2


Half Bathrooms

1


Appliances

Washer Dryer Allowed


Laundry Description

Washer Hookup, In Unit


Fireplace

Yes


Fireplace Description

Bedroom


Cooling

Yes


Cooling Description

Central Air


Heating

No

Exterior/Building Features

Lot Size

0.06 Acres

Other Property Details

Taxes

$20,100


Tax Frequency

Annually


Garage

No


View

No


View Description

Other


County

Kings


Pool

No

Listing History

Date

Event

Price

9/16/2023

Price Change

$8,950,000

-11%

Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate with Monica Luque,
Listing Contact: (212) 712-6089 

This information is not verified for authenticity or accuracy and is not guaranteed and may not reflect all real estate activity in the market.

©2024 The Real Estate Board of New York, Inc., All rights reserved

Data last updated 10:20 PM UTC, 5/13/2024

 

Powered byLuxury Presence