Which Siesta Key Condos Resold Above Their Last Sale Price This Fall

November 19, 2026

Cream coastal condo balcony with teak seating overlooking turquoise Gulf water and a pale Siesta Key beach, with neighboring balconies at the edge of the frame.

Two 860-square-foot condominiums on Cove II Place each sold for $535,000 this fall. The first, at Midnight Cove, closed in the week of September 7 and had last sold for $640,000 in 2023, according to Your Observer's weekly sales column. The second, at Midnight Cove II, closed in the last week of October and had last sold for $241,000 in 2008, per the Nov. 12 column.

The two units are the same size and sold at the same price on the same street. Measured against its prior sale, one closed about $105,000 below and the other about $294,000 above. The same spread shows up across the Siesta Key condo resales Your Observer printed in its weekly top-sales column for deeds recorded between July 20 and October 30, 2026. On the island this season, the year a unit last changed hands tells you more about how its resale went than the building does. For a buyer comparing listings now, that year is the first thing to look up.

Every 2022 Purchase Resold for Less

The column lists each sale with the unit's prior sale price and year. Five Siesta Key condos last bought in 2022 resold between late July and October 2026, and all five closed below that 2022 price.

Complex 2026 sale Prior sale Change
Sandy Cove $643,000 $829,000 in 2022 about −22%
Jamaica Royale $615,000 $779,000 in 2022 about −21%
The Inlet $550,000 $650,000 in 2022 about −15%
Siesta on the Rocks $1.68 million $1.83 million in 2022 about −8%
Our House at the Beach $800,000 $819,000 in 2022 about −2%

The Sandy Cove and Our House at the Beach sales ran in the Oct. 15 column, Jamaica Royale in the Oct. 1 column, The Inlet in the Nov. 5 column and Siesta on the Rocks in the Sept. 10 column.

Units last bought in 2023 split. Three resold below their 2023 price: one at Turtle Bay at $605,000 against $735,000, one at La Siesta at $570,000 against $655,000 per the Aug. 20 column, and the Midnight Cove unit above. Four resold above it. A Windward Passage unit sold for $2.03 million against $1.7 million, per the Sept. 17 column, and a Beach Way Apartments unit sold for $730,000 against $550,000, per the Sept. 3 column. A unit at The Pointe on Midnight Pass sold for $670,000 against $617,500, and one at The Terrace sold for $1.3 million against $1.26 million, according to the Oct. 22 column.

Island prices peaked in 2022, according to Siesta Sand's December 2025 market column. A 2022 price is a peak price. A unit last sold that year has less room between its prior sale and today's market than a unit from any other year in the sample, and this fall every one of them closed under that line.

One Complex, Four Different Results

Jamaica Royale at 5830 Midnight Pass Road shows the pattern within a single complex. Four of its units sold between late July and October. The one last bought in 2022 sold for $615,000 against $779,000. Another 921-square-foot unit, last bought in 2019 for $495,000, sold for $525,000, per the Sept. 17 column. A third sold for $550,000 against $472,500 in 2006, and a fourth for $650,000 against $105,000 in 1984, according to the Aug. 27 and Aug. 13 columns.

The four 2026 prices fall between $525,000 and $650,000. The prior prices run from $105,000 to $779,000, and the only resale that closed below its last sale was the one with the highest prior price.

Units last bought before 2021 show the pattern from the other direction. A Gulf and Bay Club unit sold for $965,000 against a 2020 price of $599,900, per the Oct. 15 column. A House of the Sun unit sold for $880,000 against $750,000 in 2020, and a Harbour Towne unit sold for $730,000 against $520,000 in 2017, according to the Sept. 24 column. Their prior prices leave room to negotiate and still close above the last sale.

The Units Bought After the Storms

The biggest gains on a short hold went to units bought after Hurricanes Helene and Milton. In the weeks after the 2024 storms, the island's condo market nearly stopped. Siesta Sand reported 21 condo closings between September 26 and December 9, 2024, against 59 in the same window a year earlier. In the first quarter of 2025, condo sales fell to 49 from 112 a year earlier and median time to contract rose to 104 days, according to the paper's April 2025 market column.

Units bought during that lull have already resold higher. A Crystal Sands unit at 6300 Midnight Pass Road sold in late September for $1.7 million after a 2024 sale at $1.27 million, per the Oct. 8 column. A Sarasota Surf and Racquet Club unit sold in September for $1.8 million against a 2025 price of $1.4 million, per the Sept. 24 column. A Siesta Gulf View unit on Beach Road sold for $1.7 million against $1.45 million in 2025, according to the Sept. 17 column.

All three gains came at $1.7 million and up. Seven of the eight 2022 and 2023 declines above sold for $800,000 or less. That fits what Sarasota Magazine reported for the third quarter of 2026. Ten Sarasota County condos and townhomes sold for $10 million or more that quarter, compared with none a year earlier, and the magazine described the top of the market as "in a league of its own."

A high price doesn't guarantee a gain, though. One unit at Siesta Key Beach Residences on Seaside Drive sold for $2.25 million in mid-October 2025, per Your Observer. The same unit sold again in early August 2026 for $2.10 million, according to the Aug. 20 column. That is $150,000 below the 2025 price about ten months later, and as with the 2022 resales, the prior price set the outcome.

Building Costs Widen the Gap

The prior sale year sets the starting point. A building's own capital work can move the final number further. Harbor Towers, the 50-year-old complex at 5855 Midnight Pass Road, finished a roughly $13 million renovation in late summer 2024. The work covered hurricane-rated glass, exterior wall reconstruction and waterproofing, and the roof was replaced after Milton. Siesta Sand reported per-unit assessments from the low $40,000s to nearly $100,000 depending on unit size, as of its September 2026 story.

At that scale, what a unit has cost its owner can sit well above its recorded purchase price. A buyer of a unit where that work is already done is getting something a lower-priced unit in an unrenovated building doesn't have. Siesta Sand's September 2025 market update said dated properties were selling at a discount. We share figures like these as general market information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Any buyer should confirm a building's assessments and finances with their attorney and financial advisor.

The County Numbers Going Into Season

Countywide, conditions are firmer than they were a year ago. In September 2026, the Sarasota County condo and townhouse median sale price was $335,000, up 6.3 percent from September 2025, according to the Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee's monthly report. Median time to contract fell to 77 days from 108, and supply fell to 4.9 months from 6.8. Sellers received a median 93.0 percent of their original list price, up from 88.3 percent a year earlier.

The same Sarasota Magazine report noted that county condo medians in the third quarter of 2026 remained below levels recorded through much of 2022, 2023 and 2024. Broker Wood, quoted in the piece, described the pandemic-era market this way: "That was never a realistic market." He also said he has met owners willing to accept considerably less than their asking prices. Nearly 61 percent of the county's condo and townhome purchases that quarter were paid in cash.

With the county median still under its 2022 to 2024 range, the island's resales this fall sort into two groups heading into the 2026–27 season. Units last bought before 2021 or after the storms closed above their prior price. Units last bought in 2022 closed below it, by 2 to 22 percent in the five sales above.

A Few Direct Questions

Is the Your Observer column a full record of Siesta Key condo sales? No. The column prints a selection of the week's top residential sales across Sarasota, Siesta Key, Palmer Ranch, Osprey and Nokomis, so it's a sample of island resales, not every closing.

Does a resale below its 2022 price mean the building lost value? Not on its own. At Jamaica Royale, the same season produced one resale below a 2022 price and three above prior prices from 1984, 2006 and 2019, with all four closing within $125,000 of each other.

Where else can I read about the island? Our Siesta Key neighborhood guide and our earlier post on Siesta Key's neighborhoods and lifestyles cover the island beyond its condo market.

If you're weighing a Siesta Key condo this season, The Holt Team can go through the recent resales at the complexes on your list with you before you make an offer. Owners curious where their own purchase year leaves them can start with a home valuation. Request a Consultation.

Stay Informed

Interested in subscribing to our newsletters? Click below to receive our emails to make sure you never miss a beat (we won't blow up your inbox). Choose from Holt's Trending, Off-Market Listings, Holt's Monthly Market, and Open House List.

Work With Us

The Holt Team is renowned for their unmatched ability to connect buyers with their dream properties and help sellers achieve their real estate aspirations. They understand that the ultimate determination of success is not awards or accolades, but the admiration of their clients. It's this unwavering commitment to client satisfaction that has earned them a loyal following and countless accolades.